What makes a show-cause letter procedurally fair?

The Fair Work Commission tests a later dismissal against section 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009. For the show-cause stage that means: each allegation is particularised (what happened, when, where, who was involved) so the employee knows exactly what to answer; the letter puts allegations without making findings or prejudging the outcome; the employee gets a genuine opportunity to respond before any decision (s.387(b)-(c)); and a support person is not unreasonably refused at any discussion (s.387(d)). A letter that announces the outcome, or alleges vague 'inappropriate conduct' with no detail, undermines the whole process.

What should each allegation include?

Enough particulars for the employee to actually respond: what is alleged to have happened, when (dates and, where relevant, times), where, and who was involved or witnessed it. One allegation per numbered item — do not roll several incidents into one vague allegation. If the employee asks for more detail, provide it where available; refusing reasonable requests for particulars weakens the fairness of the process.

How long should I give the employee to respond?

There is no fixed number in the Fair Work Act — the test is whether the employee had a genuine opportunity to respond. As a guide, 2-5 business days suits most matters, with longer for complex allegations, multiple allegations, or where the employee needs documents or advice to respond. Unreasonably short windows (such as 24 hours to answer serious allegations) are a common reason processes are criticised. If the employee asks for more time, granting a reasonable extension is usually the safer course and this template invites them to ask.

Can I suspend the employee while I investigate?

Generally yes, on full pay, as a neutral step pending the outcome — suspension on pay is a standard way to manage serious allegations without prejudging them. Check the applicable award, enterprise agreement, and the employment contract first: unpaid suspension is generally only available where an instrument or the contract expressly allows it, and some instruments set conditions on suspension. Make clear in writing that the suspension is not a disciplinary outcome.

What happens if the employee doesn't respond?

If the deadline passes with no response and no request for an extension, you can generally make a decision on the information available — but first confirm the employee actually received the letter, and consider a short follow-up or extension, especially if they are absent or unwell. Document each step. A decision made after a genuine, documented opportunity to respond is far more defensible than one made after a single unanswered letter.

Do small businesses need a show-cause letter?

Small business employers (fewer than 15 employees) are assessed against the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. For dismissals other than summary dismissal, the Code expects a valid reason, a warning that the employee is at risk of dismissal, and an opportunity to respond and improve — and it allows the employee to have another person present in discussions. A show-cause letter is strong written evidence that you gave that opportunity, so while the Code does not prescribe a letter, using one is the practical way to show compliance.

Show Cause Letter Template (Australia 2026)

Free template for employers putting allegations to an employee and asking them to show cause. Numbered particularised allegations, fair response window, support person offer, optional suspension on full pay. Cites the Fair Work Act 2009. Not legal advice.

Last verified: 2 August 2026Jump to calculator ↓

A defensible show-cause letter particularises every allegation (what, when, where), makes no findings, states the possible outcomes without prejudging, gives a genuine window to respond, and offers a support person. This template covers all of these.

FairWork Mate for employers

Get the employer-side answer and draft your response

“I'm the employer and I'm preparing a show-cause letter. Help me check the allegations, the process and the wording before I send it. Here are the details:”

Get the employer-side answer and draft your response with the AI advisor. Business Solo is Pro for employers — everything in Pro plus the full AI HR team, employer-framed answers and branded documents. A$49.99/mo, cancel anytime.

Ask the advisor as an employer →

Your question opens in the advisor ready to finish. Nothing is sent until you press send.

For business owners and HR — answers grounded in your award and the Fair Work Act, draft letters and responses. Business Solo A$49.99/mo (Pro plus the AI HR team), or Pro A$29.99/mo. Cancel anytime. See the business plans

Need a lawyer? Liquid Employment Lawyers is FairWork Mate's paid legal partner for employers facing claims. Enquiries are free with no obligation. They explain the scope and fees before any work. Talk to Liquid Employment Lawyers

Get pay and rights updates for your job

Free email updates when award rates, the minimum wage or workplace laws change.

Free forever. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

General information and estimates only — not legal, financial or tax advice. Always check your specific award, agreement or contract, or a qualified professional, before you rely on the result.

Show Cause Letter Template (Australia 2026)

Sender (manager)

Recipient (employee)

Allegations

Response window

Process options

Why show-cause processes fail at the FWC

Get the employer-side answer and draft your response

Related Tools