Skip to main content
FairWorkMate

7 Red Flags in Your Employment Contract That Are Actually Illegal (2026)

|2 min read

These 7 clauses in your employment contract may be illegal or unenforceable under Australian law. Pay secrecy, sham contracting, NES overrides, and more.

AINeed an answer for your situation? Ask FairWork Mate AI →
MC

Leave & Entitlements Specialist · JD, Monash University — Admitted in Victoria (non-practising)

Red Flag 1: Pay secrecy clauses (ILLEGAL since June 2023)

Since 7 June 2023, pay secrecy clauses in employment contracts are prohibited under the Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Secure Jobs, Better Pay) Act 2022. You've the legal right to discuss your pay with anyone — colleagues, friends, family, or your union. If your contract contains a clause that prohibits you from disclosing your salary, that clause is void and unenforceable.

Employers who include pay secrecy terms in new contracts or take adverse action against employees for discussing pay face penalties. This reform was introduced to help close the gender pay gap and improve pay transparency.

Red Flag 2: Sham contracting — classified as a contractor when you're an employee

If your contract calls you an independent contractor but you work like an employee — set hours, employer's tools, cannot subcontract, told how to do the work, work exclusively for one business — you may be a victim of sham contracting. This is illegal under section 357 of the Fair Work Act and carries penalties up to $93,900 per breach for the employer. Sham contracting denies you minimum wage protections, superannuation, leave entitlements, workers compensation, and unfair dismissal rights.

If you suspect sham contracting, contact the Fair Work Ombudsman.

Red Flag 3: Clauses that override your award or NES minimums

Your employment contract can't provide less than the National Employment Standards or your applicable Modern Award. Any clause that attempts to do so is void. Common examples include: paying below the award rate, providing less than 4 weeks annual leave, requiring you to forfeit accrued leave, or setting notice periods shorter than NES minimums.

The contract can provide better conditions than the award or NES, but never worse. If your contract tries to override these minimums, the NES/award provisions apply regardless.

Red Flag 4: Unreasonable non-compete or restraint of trade

Non-compete clauses are only enforceable in Australia if they are reasonable in scope (the activities restrained), geography (the area covered), and duration (how long the restraint lasts). Courts frequently strike down restraints that are too broad — for example, restraining you from working in your entire industry, nationwide, for 2+ years. A reasonable restraint might cover a specific competing business, within a limited geographic area, for 3-6 months.

If you are asked to sign an unreasonable non-compete, you can negotiate or seek legal advice. Even if you sign it, an Australian court may refuse to enforce it.

Red Flag 5: Unreasonable after-hours availability requirements

Since 26 August 2024, eligible employees have the right to disconnect under the Fair Work Act. This means you can refuse to monitor, read, or respond to employer contact outside your working hours unless the refusal is unreasonable. Contracts that require 24/7 availability or on-call without compensation may breach this right.

Whether a refusal is unreasonable depends on the reason for contact, how disruptive it is, whether you're compensated for being available, and your role and level of responsibility.

Red Flag 6: No notice period or below-NES notice provisions

The NES sets minimum notice periods based on length of service: 1 week (under 1 year), 2 weeks (1-3 years), 3 weeks (3-5 years), and 4 weeks (5+ years), plus an extra week if the employee is over 45 with 2+ years of service. Your contract must meet or exceed these minimums. A contract with no notice clause, or one that specifies less than the NES minimum, isn't compliant.

The NES minimums will apply regardless of what the contract says.

Red Flag 7: Automatic forfeiture of accrued leave

Some contracts include use-it-or-lose-it clauses for annual leave. Under the NES, annual leave accumulates year to year and cannot be forfeited. While an employer can direct an employee with an excessive balance (8+ weeks) to take leave, they can't simply cancel or forfeit accrued leave.

On termination, all accrued leave must be paid out. Any clause that says you lose unused leave at the end of the year is void.

Got a follow-up about this?

I'm reading "7 Red Flags in Your Employment Contract That Are Actually Illegal (2026)" on FairWork Mate. Explain how this applies in plain terms and what I should do next.

Ask FairWork Mate AI →

Have a workplace question?

Got a specific situation this article didn't cover? Ask our AI advisor.

Ask FairWork Mate AI

FairWork Mate is an independent commercial service. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or associated with the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, or any Australian Government agency. Content is general information and estimates only — not legal, financial, or tax advice. Always verify with the Fair Work Ombudsman (13 13 94) or a qualified professional.

MC
About Megan Cole

Former Fair Work Commission Associate (2021–2024) after two years as a plaintiff-side employment paralegal in Melbourne. Juris Doctor from Monash University (2020). Writes about unfair dismissal, leave entitlements, termination, and enterprise bargaining. Admitted in Victoria, currently non-practising. Based in Fitzroy North.

Real-world cases on this topic

Fair Work and Federal Court decisions that hit on what you just read.

All decisions →

Recommended partners

Free tools surface the issue. Our partners help you solve it.

Authorised Employment Hero Partner

Employment Hero

Australian HR, payroll, rostering and award interpretation in one platform. Used by 300,000+ businesses. Fixes the underlying payroll/compliance issues our calculators surface.

Best for: SMEs that have outgrown spreadsheet payroll or want automated award interpretation.

See Employment Hero

Law Tram — lawyer matching

Law Tram

Matched with the right Australian lawyer for your situation — unfair dismissal, underpayment, workplace injury, debt, tenancy and more. Many lawyers offer a free first consult and no-win-no-fee arrangements.

Best for: anyone whose workplace or personal legal issue needs proper advice, not just a calculator.

Find a lawyer

IT, Microsoft & cyber partner

Frontrow Tech

Microsoft 365, Copilot rollouts, Essential Eight, Privacy Act 2026 and board-level cyber compliance for Australian SMBs. Where pay and HR end, your data and IT obligations begin.

Best for: SMBs running on Microsoft 365, anyone hitting cyber/privacy compliance, boards wanting an outside read on IT risk.

See Frontrow

Affiliate partners — commissions fund the free tools on this site. We only recommend partners we've vetted as a good fit for Australian workplaces.